When comparing magnesium oxide (MgO) sheathing to oriented strand board (OSB) sheathing, several key differences exist in their properties, applications, and performance. Here's a breakdown of how these two materials stack up:
Fire Resistance
MgO Sheathing: Naturally fire-resistant, MgO sheathing offers superior fire protection, often achieving fire ratings suitable for building code compliance in fire-rated wall assemblies. Many MgO panels have been tested to meet stringent fire standards, providing peace of mind for applications where fire resistance is critical. MgO boards are naturally non-combustible, meaning they do not require additional chemical treatments to achieve fire resistance. They have high fire ratings (up to 1-4 hours, depending on the product and configuration) and do not release toxic smoke when exposed to fire. This makes MgO a strong choice for building codes that require fire-rated assemblies and for applications where fire safety is a top concern.
OSB Sheathing: OSB is combustible and does not offer inherent fire resistance. Although fire-rated OSB options are available, these rely on chemical treatments and specialized coatings that add to the cost and may not be as inherently fireproof as MgO. OSB does not have inherent fire-resistant properties. Fire-rated OSB products are treated with fire-resistant chemicals, which help delay combustion but do not offer the same level of natural fire resistance as MgO. Treated OSB can be effective, but its fire resistance generally does not match the durability of MgO in high-heat conditions.
Fire-Retardant Treated Wood (FRTW): FRTW is wood chemically treated to resist ignition and slow the spread of flames. While it improves over untreated wood, it remains less fire-resistant than MgO sheathing. FRTW also requires maintenance, as the treatment may degrade over time, especially in wet or humid conditions, further lowering its effectiveness in fire scenarios.
Moisture and Mold Resistance
MgO Sheathing: It is highly resistant to moisture and does not support mold or mildew growth, making it suitable for areas prone to high humidity or water exposure. Its performance is stable under wet conditions, which helps maintain durability and structural integrity.
OSB Sheathing: OSB is vulnerable to water damage and can swell, delaminate, or support mold growth if not adequately protected with a water-resistant barrier. OSB is generally not recommended for areas with persistent moisture unless treated and protected.
Environmental Impact and Sustainability
MgO Sheathing: MgO boards generally have a lower carbon footprint than wood-based panels due to the cleaner manufacturing process, which involves abundant natural resources like magnesium from seawater or brine pools. MgO sheathing also typically contains fewer chemicals, making it a sustainable choice.
OSB Sheathing: OSB is made from wood fibers bonded with adhesives, which often contain formaldehyde and other chemicals. However, OSB can be produced from fast-growing, renewable wood sources, which can be beneficial if sustainably managed.
Structural Performance
MgO Sheathing: MgO boards provide high impact and flexural strength, offering excellent dimensional stability. They can handle significant shear forces, making them suitable for structural applications when specified. MgO boards have excellent structural properties, particularly in fastener withdrawal and shear strength. They can handle significant structural loads and are highly durable against impact and flexing, making them comparable or superior to traditional materials like gypsum and cement board. MgO’s high density contributes to its strength, which also helps it resist warping, cracking, and bending under pressure. These properties are ideal for load-bearing wall assemblies or exterior sheathing that withstand wind, seismic forces, or impacts.
OSB Sheathing: OSB sheathing provides high shear strength and is commonly used in structural wall and roof assemblies. It’s engineered to distribute loads effectively, which has made it a go-to in structural framing applications for decades. OSB is known for its strength in shear applications, so it’s widely used in wall and roof sheathing. However, OSB’s strength can diminish if exposed to moisture, as it is prone to swelling and delamination. In addition, it may not perform as well as MgO sheathing in fastener withdrawal, significantly if affected by humidity, which can lead to loosening fasteners over time.
Gypsum and Cement Board: While gypsum and some cement boards are typically used in wall assemblies for fire-rated walls, they usually lack the structural strength of MgO. These materials are brittle and have lower impact resistance, which limits their use in applications where durability and structural integrity are essential.
Comparative Advantages of MgO Sheathing Board
All-in-One Performance: MgO sheathing can often eliminate the need for multiple layers of different materials (like gypsum and OSB) to achieve fire resistance, structural support, and moisture resistance in one panel, which streamlines construction.
Resistance to Moisture: Unlike OSB, which can swell or degrade in wet environments, MgO boards naturally resist water damage, mold, and mildew. This makes them suitable for exterior and interior applications, especially in climates where moisture concerns them.
Enhanced Sustainability: MgO sheathing, sourced from abundant magnesium, offers a lower carbon footprint than many wood-based materials and does not rely on petrochemical-based adhesives.
Installation and Workability
MgO Sheathing: MgO boards are often lighter than traditional cement-based boards, though they can still weigh more than OSB. MgO panels are usually straightforward to cut and install, but special attention to waterproofing and fastener placement is necessary to prevent expansion from moisture.
OSB Sheathing: OSB is more accessible for cutting and nailing, and it's widely recognized by builders, making it more straightforward to source and install. However, depending on the project, additional water and fire protection measures may be required.
Cost Consideration
MgO Sheathing: MgO panels are typically more expensive upfront than OSB due to their superior fire, moisture, and mold resistance properties. However, they may reduce costs in fire-rated assemblies by eliminating the need for additional fire-rated layers.
OSB Sheathing: OSB is widely used due to its cost-effectiveness and ready availability, making it a budget-friendly choice for non-fire-rated and interior applications.
Health and Indoor Air Quality
MgO Sheathing: MgO boards are free from harmful chemicals like formaldehyde and asbestos, contributing to healthier indoor air quality, especially for sensitive individuals.
OSB Sheathing: OSB often contains adhesives that may emit volatile organic compounds (VOCs), including formaldehyde, although low-emission options are available.
Conclusion
MgO sheathing outperforms OSB in fire resistance, moisture resistance, and durability, making it ideal for high-performance buildings or areas where these factors are critical. OSB remains a popular and economical choice for general structural applications but may require additional fire and water resistance measures. The choice between MgO and OSB sheathing will ultimately depend on the project's specific performance needs, environmental considerations, and budget constraints. MgO sheathing has a distinct edge over OSB and FRTW regarding fire resistance, structural durability, and long-term reliability. It offers a high-performing solution for buildings that prioritize fire safety, structural integrity, and moisture resilience. While OSB and FRTW have their place in general construction, MgO sheathing can be a game-changer for projects requiring higher-performance materials across multiple criteria.
JP Group -- MagMatrix BMSC 517 New Sulfate MGO Sheathing Panel is the third generation of the new sulfate MGO board with ints 517 microstructure hydration crystal of the panel body over 70% that already listed on the international inorganic crystal data center in German. We are the first to make this technology breakthrough worldwide, and we have made the magnesium cement board with significant advantages over OSB sheathing, gypsum-based sheathing, and Portland cement board sheathing. For more information, don't hesitate to get in touch with us.
Comments